Oct. 24, 2018

COLUMBIA, Mo. --- The Michael Porter Sr. Family is basketball royalty ... the mom, the dad, the children.

Not just in Central Missouri, not just around the state, but around the nation. The Porter House seemed to be living the charmed, basketball dream ... taking it a step further, the sister of the family's matriarch, Lisa, is Robin Pingeton, the Missouri women's basketball coach.

But the dream has turned into basketball agony, an ominous sky of black clouds and bad luck.

The latest jolt came Sunday when 6-11 Missouri Tigers sophomore Jontay Porter suffered a season-ending knee injury after tearing both his ACL and MCL during a scrimmage against Southern Illinois.

That was the third blow to the Porters --- not to mention MU's basketball programs and Tiger fans --- in the last 11 months.

MU's Michael Porter Jr. --- the 6-10 superstar who was regarded as a top two or three NBA draft pick --- was basically lost for the season last November with a back injury. In June, women's star, 6-4 Ciara Porter, announced her retirement because of recurring knee injuries.

And it all started in 2016, when 6-3 Bri Porter suffered the fifth ACL injury of her career, forcing her to quit playing basketball for the Tigers.

It's more than any family should endure, basketball or not. But why and how did this happen?

Because it can't be a coincidence.

Is it because they got so big, so fast at such a young age? Would it have happened if they were 5-11 instead of 6-11 at age 17, because their bodies just couldn't mature fast enough to handle the massive growth spurts?

"Intuitively, I would say yes," said Dr. Mike Snyder, an orthopedic surgeon and sports medicine specialist with the Jefferson City Medical Group. "But I haven't seen any studies that says that's the case."

Then what is it?

THE PLAYING SURFACE

"These turf fields and basketball courts are so much better now," Dr. Snyder said. "And for lack of a medical term, the stickier they are and the more traction you get, the more dangerous they are.

"When you plant your foot and your foot doesn't give, that stress gets transmitted up to your ankle, your knee and your hips. Something's gotta give."

In this case, being a great athlete at a young age can actually be a detriment.

"The bigger and stronger you are," Snyder continued, "the higher your risk of some type of injury. When you come down from a jumping position or you cut, the amount of torque and stress that you can put on your knee is multiples of your body weight, like five or six times.

"If you're a strong kid and you can turn and rip, you're going to put much more demand on your ACL. It's not just how much you weigh, it's the fact that they're so strong that they create a greater joint reactive force.

"It doesn't matter if it's your hip, your ankle or your knee."

TOO MUCH, TOO YOUNG ... AND NOT JUST THE PORTERS

"There was a study done 10 years ago in Florida," Snyder said, "where they followed the Detroit Tigers in the minor leagues, and a little league baseball tournament involving 12 year-olds. And the little leaguers threw 10 times as many pitches in a week.

"These kids are playing a million baseball games or basketball games, they're lifting year-round, and their muscles get fatigued. When your muscles get fatigued --- and it's your muscles that are kind of your protectors to whatever joint it is --- that makes your joints more likely to become injured."

Snyder continued.

"These kids, too many of them, just don't take any time off," he said. "If you look at elite athletes, the guys who are getting paid for this, their trainers schedule blocks of time off, just so their muscles can recoup. You can't go 24-7, 365, your body can't take that, you'll actually go downward.

"Studies have shown that if you take a month off and then start training again, you'll actually have greater jumps in your performance because you've given you body a chance to recoup."

What you do at age 12 can have an impact when you're 17 or 18.

"There's absolutely a cumulative effect," Snyder said. "The incidents of Tommy John surgery, in 14-16 year-old males, has gone up 28 percent in the last five years. It's because a lot of these kids are getting pushed, thinking the more you play, the better you get.

"That's not necessarily true ... you've got to give your body breaks. In studies, most of these injuries are driven by overuse. Some parents are nuts, they push and push and push their kids, like throwing 120 pitches in a baseball game to win a little trophy."

This is not the case with the Porters, Snyder insists.

"I want to be really clear on this, I'm not talking about the Porters' parents because they get it, they're great people," he said. "They haven't pushed these kids, they played because they love the game.

"In the case of the Porters, it's pure genetics."

GENETICS ... AND BAD LUCK

"Genetics play a real factor in injuries like the strength of your ligaments, the laxity in your ligaments, and your body-mass index. Some people just have weaker ligaments, some people have weaker backs, it's the way they're built."

Porter Jr. and his herniated disc is a prime example. He's jumped tens of thousands of times in his life, but that's not the problem --- it's when he lands.

But ...

"It's not just the impacts, it's all the hyper-extension (when your back goes backwards) he does that puts a load on your disc space," Snyder said. "That can lead not only to a herniated disc, but stress fractures. 

"Having said that, it's almost unheard of for an 18 year-old to have this, like 1 in 10,000."

There's another good example of the genetics at work, right here in Jefferson City.

"Look and Mike and Kirk Farmer, both of them hurt, constantly," Snyder said. "I wasn't here went Mike was here (in the 1960s), but Kirk Farmer (1990s) is built like a Greek Adonis and he couldn't make it through a season.

"He got hurt his junior year with the Jays, he got hurt every year he was at Mizzou --- broke his leg, broke his hand, broke his collarbone. It was every, stinkin' year. If you looked at him, he was the last person you'd think would get hurt.

"Some people, genetically, are just not as strong in their bones or ligaments. And there's absolutely nothing you can do about it.

"And honestly, with the Porters, I think there's also been a lot of bad luck."

The Porter injuries: Dr. Snyder
says several factors go into it

Missouri sophomore Jontay Porter's injury is the fourth in the family the last two years.

Loeffler's Link